Episode 61 - How to Build a Signature Program and a Niche Practice: Lessons from CFO Mentor Alena Bennett

Jane Anderson Director & Executive Leadership Consultant, CFO Mentor, Chartered Accountant, Author Alena Bennett

Podcast is also available on the versions below:

Get Notified Of Future Episodes on Apple Podcasts | Spotify


 

What does it take to go from being very good at your technical craft to running a practice built around a signature program, a clear niche and a community of people you genuinely want to work with?

In this episode of The Jane Anderson Show, I sat down with Alena Bennett, a chartered accountant, executive leadership consultant, CFO mentor and author who has spent around 20 years working in finance in Australia and the US. Alena now works with chief financial officers through the CFO Boardroom, a 12-month coaching program and community. She is just as open about the messy parts of the journey as she is about the wins.

Her story takes in the "shiny toy" early years, a book written as a deliberate bet on a niche, a part-time contract that bought her time to build, and the careful design of her signature program. If you are a consultant, coach or advisor thinking about your next step, including the women in my Women With Influence community, there is plenty here to borrow.

A note on timing: Alena recorded this conversation while she was still building the CFO Boardroom, so figures such as pricing, list size and cohort size reflect that moment rather than today.

From Technical Finance to Work She Loved

Alena trained as an accountant and auditor in Australia and the US. Along the way she noticed two things: people kept coming to her for help, and leadership had a clear effect, good and bad, on team performance. Back in Australia she specialised in sampling, did advisory work with engagement teams and moved into KPMG's technical advisory department. After having her two children she decided partnership was never really her path, so she moved into corporate, partly to avoid being pigeonholed as an auditor.

That shift gave her the language for performance, culture and leadership. In her job interview she was told the company needed to roll out an internal controls framework. She said yes, on the condition that embedding it would require work on the finance culture, and the company agreed.

A couple of years later, at a leadership strategy day in Melbourne, she watched the facilitator and had what she describes as her "that's what I want to do when I grow up" moment. She was in her thirties and had no idea that coaching, facilitating, training and speaking were careers. She asked to pick the facilitator's brain, and he was generous with his time and introduced her to other people.

What became clear was where her value sat. She knew the technical side and could do it, but her strengths were relationships and influence, so she wanted to partner with smart finance professionals who needed leadership skills to lift their results. An invitation from a consultant to join an internal project outside finance gave her what she calls a soft landing, which mattered given the "am I qualified to do this?" doubts that come with a lot of qualifications. She worked on it for about a year. The distance rekindled her passion, and she started the "baby version" of her practice.

The Shiny Toy Years and the Pressure of Survival Mode

Alena is candid about the early stage. She did all of it at once, which she puts down to "shiny toy syndrome", and the delivery was good. But, as she says, delivery is just one piece of the pie. I added that the infrastructure around delivery is what makes a practice work, and she agreed.

She knew finance was where she wanted to play. Like a lot of people at that stage, though, she also needed to sustain the business, so she cast the net wide. She had heard the advice to pick a niche, but a scarcity voice kept asking what she might be missing out on.

Over several years the revenue was not quite replacing itself and the runway was burning down. She is the breadwinner in her family, the dynamic was starting to shift and they had two very young girls, which added uncertainty.

Writing a Book to Commit to a Niche

Alena describes her first book as a bit of a Hail Mary, borrowing the American football term from her American husband. Her thinking was that niching had to be a thing, so she wrote a book for women in finance. She also felt that after a few years in business she should have a book anyway.

The book was released right before the pandemic, and the gender conversation fell off the radar for a while, so it did not transform her revenue. It made a difference in other ways. Holding a book gave her a sense that there was real substance in her work. She already knew it was good because she had been teaching it for years, but other people reacted too, asking her to talk with them or to speak to their teams.

That gave her the impetus to decide she really wanted to be in this game. She also understood she needed more runway. Survival mode, she says, does nothing for your delivery, and in sales meetings the desperation shows.

If you are weighing up your own first book, you may enjoy how Dr Michelle Gibbings approached the fear of publishing her first book in episode 101.

Buying Runway with a Part-Time Contract

While skimming her emails, Alena spotted a part-time role in the careers section of a Chartered Accountants Australia and New Zealand message, in an area where she had particular expertise. She suspected a former KPMG colleague led the team, so she reached out. Over coffee she told her that the interested person was herself.

She was honest about her reasons. She wanted to protect the brand she had been working hard on, and she also admitted she was lonely. She thrives around a team and felt that energy was missing. Her former colleague thought the role was below her pay grade. Alena explained it had nothing to do with career trajectory; she wanted something that worked alongside her business.

She got the role: a 12-month contract of roughly two to three days a week, although she was not certain of the exact days. With the pandemic and lockdown arriving, it gave her a team she enjoyed and certainty of cash flow, which kept the foundation going while she kept building.

Timing mattered. Alena believes that if she had taken a contract 12 months earlier she might have seen it through a lens of failure. The book helped her treat it as a strategic play that would give her the foundation, the energy and the certainty to remove the negative energy of not being where she wanted to be.

Managing Your Energy

Running a contract on top of a business is hard, because the business is effectively a full-time job already. Alena says she was intentional about why the contract existed and about the energy she gave it. As a high performer she would normally have asked to do more, but she had to temper her expectations, knowing anything extra she gave the contract was taken from her business.

She was also transparent. The team knew the role sat alongside her business, and in the interview they asked why someone with a successful business wanted a job. Her conviction about the "why" carried her through. She had her husband on board for what she knew would be a tough year, and towards the end of it she told me she did not know how she was doing it, because her business was growing quickly.

Knowing When To Renegotiate

I asked Alena what tipped her into running her practice full time. Her answer was time and fatigue, and the contract coming to an end. They asked her to extend, and she did, partly because she was scared to let go of the certainty. She extended on her terms, working on discrete pieces on an invoice basis rather than as a part-time employee.

That variability eventually suited neither side. Then, about a month before we recorded, she was asked to contribute to a curriculum. Her day rate, the value of her time and the value of her IP had changed so much that she told them it would need an IP licence or another arrangement. They told her they do not enter into those arrangements, so the work ended on good terms.

I loved this part of her story. It is easy to feel that because you made a decision, you have to stay with it. Alena instead had an open conversation about where her value now sat. You can give yourself permission to grow.

Choosing CFOs and Designing a Signature Program

About a year before we recorded, Alena and I talked about her next step. She had niched into women in finance, and I asked who she really wanted to work with. She chose CFOs, because they sit at the top of the tree and can have the most impact and influence, both with their teams and across a leadership team and organisation.

She also wanted two other things. After her contract experience she wanted a group of great people around her. And she wanted a signature program that people would know her for: "Alena does this, and she runs a community for CFOs." She is not someone who needs to be in the spotlight, and her favourite mode of working is coaching and facilitating, where she gets to bring people together and be the connector.

The result is the CFO Boardroom, which she describes as her high performance coaching program and platinum community for CFOs. Alongside it she runs CFOs Connect, a bigger group of CFOs who come together on a semi-regular basis. She likens it to a "CFO Boardroom light". Her goal for the following year was to take these communities across the eastern seaboard, once travel restrictions allowed.

Alena's reasoning for building a community was practical. CFOs and finance professionals are good at internal networks but tend to get the blinkers on. They also do not want to go to a mass conference and do speed networking. What she keeps hearing is that they value a safe, genuine environment where they can say, "this is me." She also wanted to avoid the work feeling transactional, which is why the community and the 12-month length matter.

The Problem the Program Solves

Alena explains that the CFO role is evolving, and in her view the pandemic put CFOs in the spotlight as people who can keep companies safe and also drive strategic direction. The CFO Boardroom is for those who want that journey, including those who want to be the CEO's right hand and change the communities they work in. Not all CFOs do, and she is fine with that.

A big part of the work is helping CFOs define their own brand. There is a school of thought that CEO is the natural next step. Alena disagrees. She sees them as two different roles with different capabilities, and says you need a genuine desire to be a CEO. Her challenge to CFOs is to forget the job title and "play for significance", which for her is about legacy rather than status. That could mean a CEO role, a board seat, the philanthropic space or becoming a virtual CFO for multiple companies. When a brand is aligned with purpose, she finds the confidence and presence people look for show up naturally.

I pointed out that this is how good programs are designed: find the most significant problem holding your clients back, then design the solution it needs. Alena's depth of thinking about her CFOs, and her credibility from having done the job, is a big part of why the program is so clear.

Inside the CFO Boardroom: Structure, Pricing and Ease

At the time of recording, the CFO Boardroom cohort had ten people. Alena described the pillars of the 12-month program:

  • Quarterly mastermind days.

  • A two-hour check-in between quarters. She compares it to drifting towards the edge of the lane on a road trip: a prompt to get back into the middle of the lane, refocus and accelerate through the rest of the quarter.

  • One-on-one coaching, tailored to each CFO's specific goals.

  • An annual CFO of the Future community event, bringing together her CFOs and aspiring CFOs. This was one of the evolutions that came out of lockdown.

  • Webinars and insights across the 12 months.

Each CFO also creates a "play", a 90-day focus project that can deliver a business outcome, a professional outcome or a personal one. Alena shared a story about a new participant with a five-year career plan. She assumed his play would be about business or work, but he said he has three streams in his life, cricket, family and work, and wanted more balance. For Alena it was a reminder that she is bringing together smart financial minds who are also human beings with complex lives.

Pricing and making it easy to say yes

I asked Alena about the price, and she was generous in sharing it. The CFO Boardroom was a $20,000 program, excluding GST. Some CFOs have their employer sponsor the program, and others fund it personally because they understand the benefit to them. Alena splits the $20,000 in whichever way is easiest for each person.

She credits two values she sees me put into practice: generosity and ease. If someone wants to opt in a few months before the next program launches, she spreads the fee over a longer period and adds some free coaching sessions so they get a running start. She does not want money to be the pain point, and she does not want transactional relationships.

She is also clear about her confidence in the price. She is comfortable that she will give clients a minimum of $20,000 of value back. Her new business manager looked at all the zeros and found it ridiculous, but Alena's view is that it is not about the money. It is what the money lets her do, which is to be generous and solve big problems for people, and to create the lifestyle she wants for her family.

The Unglamorous Foundations: List, Systems and Discipline

Behind the launch is work that does not look glamorous. Alena started the previous year with 64 CFOs on her list and, at the time of recording, had about 800. She keeps CFOs and aspiring CFOs on separate lists, so that number refers to CFOs. Without that list, she says, it is impossible to host multiple community events and forums for CFOs. She is still a long way from big public programs, and she says you have to do the work.

Where did the discipline come from? Alena credits the pandemic period, when she attended a content bootcamp and then took a collateral-building program I was running. She followed it closely, with "skin in the game". She sees it as a turning point for her business. What she valued was the rigour and discipline around the framework. She prefers a deliberate approach and wants to know an offer is good before she sells it.

I also noted that Alena has invested in her systems and her team. At the time she had two team members, one full time offshore and one local at around 20 hours a week. She recalls me explaining how a CRM interacts with a project management system, and says Asana is now her best friend. Her view: "If you get your foundations right, that is the source of freedom." It is not sexy, she says, but it is a must-have if you want to grow a big business and serve your community.

For another look at practical systems, episode 98 with Inbal Rodnay explores capturing and reusing the conversations you are already having.

Advice for Consultants Starting Out

I asked Alena what she would tell someone listening who sees themselves in her story of a year ago. Her advice came back to a few themes.

Be clear about what you want.

Alena admits she knew what she wanted and also did not. She tried a lot of things and allowed herself to be influenced by people who perhaps were not the right people. Self-awareness about what works for you lets you politely say, "thanks, but that's not really for me" to the random advice you will receive.

Stay in your lane.

Alena says she suffers from "comparisonitis" at times. Even a CFO asked her why she did not simply work with others too. She knows that would dilute the value she can offer CFOs, and her mentors agree. She reminds herself that "there is only one of me". She is an oldest child and a people pleaser, and she says it does not help anyone if you try to be all things to all people. Some people will be further ahead or doing things that look more fun, but you play your own game.

Expect imposter syndrome.

More recently Alena has experienced a bit of it, partly because her business has been successful this year. She finds herself asking who this person is and what this business is.

Invest in a mentor.

Alena says working with a mentor changed her life. She resonated with my story before we ever worked together, and she values the generosity with my network and ideas. She gave an example: when she was second-guessing how many options to offer in a finance leadership team program, I brought her back to the value she had promised clients and the benefit they would get.

About Alena Bennett

Alena Bennett is a chartered accountant, executive leadership consultant and CFO mentor with experience across Australia and the US. She is the author of Meaning Matters: Results Beyond the Numbers and CFO of the Future, and runs the CFOs Connect Community alongside the CFO Boardroom.

🔗 Alena's website · 🔗 Connect with Alena on LinkedIn

Frequently Asked Questions

How did Alena Bennett choose a niche for her consulting practice?

She started with a broad approach and cast the net wide, then wrote a book for women in finance as a deliberate bet on niching. Later, in a conversation with me about who she most wanted to work with, she chose CFOs because they sit at the top of the tree and can have the most impact and influence with their teams and across their organisations.

What is the CFO Boardroom?

The CFO Boardroom is Alena Bennett's high performance coaching program and community for CFOs. At the time of recording it was a 12-month program with quarterly mastermind days, a two-hour check-in between quarters, one-on-one coaching, an annual CFO of the Future community event and webinars. The cohort at the time had ten people.

How much does the CFO Boardroom cost?

At the time of recording, it was a $20,000 program excluding GST. Some CFOs have their employer sponsor it and others fund it themselves. Alena splits the fee in whichever way is easiest for the person, and for early sign-ups she spreads the payments over a longer period and adds some free coaching sessions.

Can you run a part-time contract alongside your own consulting practice?

Alena did, and she describes it as a strategic decision. She took a 12-month part-time contract for cash-flow certainty and a team to work with, was transparent with her employer, and managed her energy carefully so she did not give the contract effort that belonged to her business. She advises knowing exactly why you are doing it.

How did Alena Bennett grow her list of CFOs?

She went from 64 CFOs on her list to about 800 in 12 months. She says the list is a big part of being able to host community events and forums, and that it comes down to consistency, rigour and discipline, supported by systems and a team.

How should consultants deal with comparison and imposter syndrome?

Alena recommends being clear about what you want and what works for you, staying in your lane and playing your own game. She also advises investing in a mentor who helps you return to the value you have committed to your clients.

Conclusion

Alena Bennett's practice did not take off because of one clever tactic. It grew from a series of deliberate choices: turning her finance background into her point of difference, committing to a niche with a book, using a part-time contract to buy runway, choosing the people she most wanted to serve and building the list, systems and team underneath it all.

As I said to her, her story starts with who she cares about, and it shows in how deeply she thinks about her clients' challenges and opportunities. If you are building your own signature program, the pattern is worth copying: get clear on what you want, design around a significant problem and make it easy for the right people to say yes.

Work With Jane Anderson

If Alena's story resonated with you, here are some ways to take the next step:

  • Women With Influence: Join a community of B2B women consultants, coaches and advisors building world-class practices.

  • Grow With Influence: Work with me on your positioning, signature program and the structure of your practice.

  • Free scorecards and diagnostics: Take the Known, Trusted, Chosen Scorecard to see where the gaps are in your personal brand, marketing, sales and scaling.

✨ Tune in to hear Alena's honest story of building a niche, a signature program and a community of CFOs, without losing sight of the life she wanted.

 

Key Takeaways from Today’s Episode:

 

Full Show Transcript:

 


Most of the guests interviewed are current or alumni members of the Women With Influence community. Click here to find out more

Previous
Previous

Episode 62- How to Build a Consulting Practice Through Thought Leadership and Speaking: Lessons from Ally Nitschke

Next
Next

Episode 60 - How Speakers Can Turn a Keynote Into a Speaking Album: Lessons From Chawn Bracey