Episode 62- How to Build a Consulting Practice Through Thought Leadership and Speaking: Lessons from Ally Nitschke

Jane Anderson Leadership Expert, Courageous Conversations Specialist, Speaker, Author Ally Nitschke

Podcast is also available on the versions below:

Get Notified Of Future Episodes on Apple Podcasts | Spotify


 

Do you need to be based in Sydney or Melbourne to build a consulting practice that thrives? Ally Nitschke’s experience says no. She built hers from Adelaide, starting when her youngest child was only six weeks old.

In this episode of The Jane Anderson Show, I sat down with Ally, a leadership communication expert who works with organisations to build what she calls courageous leadership, courageous conversations and courageous teams. She is the founder of Made for More, a mother of four young boys and, in a past life, a professional ballet dancer.

We talked about how she got her practice off the ground, why her first year delivered so little, and what changed once she started unpacking her ideas, publishing on a regular rhythm, valuing her expertise and speaking on stages. This article draws out the practical lessons for any consultant, coach or advisor who wants to build a consulting practice on the strength of their own experience.

Building a Consulting Practice Outside the Big Capital Cities

Ally has a ready joke about Adelaide. Most people talk about six degrees of separation, she says, but in Adelaide it is really only two: everyone knows someone who knows someone who went to school with someone’s cousin.

That small-town feel shaped her early thinking. When she first stepped into thought leadership and started building her own practice, she wondered who would pay attention to her from “little old Adelaide”. Over the twelve months before we recorded, her mindset shifted. She now says Adelaide is bigger than she assumed and that there is opportunity all over the place.

Ally also pointed to what online delivery has changed. Speakers and consultants are no longer restricted by flight times and borders, and she has found it phenomenal to connect with people internationally that she would not normally have come across or reached out to.

I raised the stories many consultants tell themselves: that all the big clients are in Sydney and Melbourne, that people in their city won’t spend, that not-for-profits don’t buy, or that nobody has a budget. Ally’s practice has tested those assumptions. As I said to her, she has “blown all those myths out of the water” by going out and finding out for herself, and her clients include not-for-profits.

Starting a Practice Before It Feels Perfect

Ally was working in the federal government and had been there for a number of years, but she felt underutilised. After maternity leave and a return to full-time work, she found the juggle okay, but it was not what she wanted her life to look like. At the time, she says, she was thinking that “the nine to five is not designed for women in the workplace”.

The idea for Made for More took shape while she was holding her six-week-old baby and applying for a new role. Her husband told her it was not the end of her chapter. Ally realised her career in the public sector had not yet reached the peak she was hoping for and, with their family complete, it was time for “game on”.

Her background is varied. She worked in banking and finance in the private sector before the public sector, and across many different industries and sectors. She does not have an HR background, which she notes is common among thought leaders in the leadership and team space. Instead, everything she teaches is based on real-life experience of great teams, not-so-great teams, great leadership and not-so-great leadership.

Her biggest lesson about building a practice is a simple one. It may be a cliche, she admits, but “you just have to get started”.

Why the First Year Delivered So Little

Ally is refreshingly honest that clients did not simply appear. She naively assumed that putting up a logo and announcing she was in business would be enough. “No, they did not just magically fall in my lap,” she says.

For the first 12 months, she only dipped her toe in. She spent a lot of time on activities that produced no real results, whether that meant revenue, clients or movement in her thought leadership.

Finding the Right Room

The turning point came when she accidentally met me at a Professional Speakers Australia (PSA) event. She had connected on Instagram with a speaker we both follow, who was visiting Adelaide, and asked him to bring a copy of his book. She walked into the event with no idea what Professional Speakers Australia was. What she found was a room full of speakers and an association built for them. “Where have you been my whole life?” was her reaction.

That mattered because Ally has been told her whole life that she has too many ideas and should calm down and focus on one thing. At the PSA, people were telling her to develop those ideas. She remembers a line from my short talk that day about needing somewhere to capture your monkeys, and thinking that her own were out of control. Soon after, we started working together in Content Club.

Unpacking Your Ideas

The work began with simple questions. What are my ideas? What do I really think about this whole leadership thing? Ally points out the irony that it took courage to put those ideas out there, given that she talks about courage for a living.

Many of us are conditioned to worry about what everyone will think, and what if we are wrong. What Ally is still learning is that it does not matter, because “it’s my perspective and it’s my experience”. She finds it validating to hold that perspective and share it.

If you want another honest account of the courage it takes to put your name and ideas into the world, my conversation with Dr Michelle Gibbings covers building a practice over many years, including writing her first book while afraid.

How Content and a Regular Cadence Turned Into Enquiries

As Ally unpacked her ideas, she became clearer on what she does that is impactful to other people and what leaders need to elevate their leadership. She is most known for courageous conversations, which come naturally to her, and the next question was how to talk about them.

The shift in enquiries followed. Once she began developing her content and publishing weekly newsletters on LinkedIn, getting that cadence into effect, people started to say they had read an article she wrote or heard a podcast she was a guest on and wanted to know how they could work together.

I also congratulated Ally on the recent recognition of her Made for More podcast among the top five podcasts in Australia. In my view, the interviews work like research. They build a bank of knowledge and advance her thinking on courage, which is the focus she has narrowed into, whether she is working with courageous leaders, teams or women.

What Moved the Needle Most

When I asked Ally which single change made the biggest difference, her answer was all of it. She describes it as a snowball effect:

Content built confidence.

Unpacking her thoughts boosted her confidence, so she put herself out there a lot more.

Valuing her expertise.

Her internal monologue used to tell her she was brand new and wondered what she thought she was doing. The shift came from remembering she had been doing this for nearly 20 years and probably did know something. It is a mindset of getting over yourself, she says, because it is not about you. This is work Ally and I have done closely together in the Women With Influence community.
A regular cadence.

Ally now plans what goes out each month and what programs she is talking about, then puts it in her calendar. On Tuesdays she does one thing, and on Fridays another.
IP and collateral.

She has brochures and materials around the products and programs she sells, so everything fits together.

From Scattergun to Strategy

When Ally first started, her approach was scattergun with no real strategy. She jokes that she might have some strategy now. Today she asks what she is doing this quarter and what she wants to do across the whole of the following year, then works back to what needs to happen.

Previously, she was in a reactive space, or what I called order taking. Now her thinking is: here is what people need, here is what I am really good at, here is how we deliver it, and here is the collateral and IP behind it.

Valuing Your Expertise and Raising Your Prices

I observed that we are often too close to our own work. We have been doing it for 20 years and assume everyone knows it. I remembered one of our early conversations, about face-to-face events that ran for an hour each. An hour in the middle of the day means you cannot sell anything else that day, so a $200 session quietly becomes a $200 day.

Ally says her pricing shift was not overnight. It happened in tiny increments, and I was there for much of the journey, telling her she was still too cheap.

Let Client Feedback Guide Your Pricing

One of the biggest shifts for Ally was the feedback she received. After a recent program with leaders from across an organisation, one participant took her aside. She was probably the most experienced person in the group and had been a general manager in a number of companies. She told Ally it was the best leadership program she had ever done.

Ally had assumed she was only telling experienced leaders what they already knew. She notes that women in particular are conditioned to brush off compliments, and she has decided to start taking some of them at face value. The conclusion she reached: “It’s okay to charge a premium price because people are getting premium results, a premium experience, a premium network.”

She also gained confidence from seeing peers in her network doing remarkable things. She says some of the women in her network are signing multi-six and multi-million dollar deals, and she thought that if they could do it, she probably could too.

Package the Solution, Not the Day

Part of the change was letting go of clients who were only prepared to pay for lower-value pieces of work. Ally began asking how to package the work up differently. Instead of a one-day lunch and learn, how could she sell eight or ten sessions, or a longer program?

I added that this comes down to the problem you are solving. The question is not “how do I sell a $40,000 program?” It is what the client is actually trying to solve, and whether that can happen in a day. Probably not. It might take three, six or 12 months, and that is the point at which a $4,000 conversation can become a $40,000 one. I am not here to take people’s money for the sake of it. The price follows the problem.

If you are working through pricing and packaging in your own practice, this is the territory my Grow With Influence program is built around.

Speaking as a Way to Build Your Consulting Practice

Ally has wanted to be a speaker for a long time. In her early twenties, a coach told her she could not yet be a motivational speaker because she needed more experience and did not have any life stories. She remembers thinking she had done quite a bit in a short time.

She also spent her childhood on stage as a professional ballet dancer before what she calls “real work”. She thrives in that performance setting, and loves being able to influence a large audience over 45 minutes to an hour and trigger different thinking and action.

A keynote takes a lot of preparation, because you want to include as much value as possible without overwhelming people. The part Ally has noticed most is the flow-on effect afterwards. She might deliver a 45-minute keynote and soon hear from the sister’s cousin of the person she sat next to, who lives in Sydney and wants to talk. For her, speaking has also been valuable for brand positioning.

For another view on how speaking builds trust before a sales conversation, listen to my conversation with Inbal Rodnay.

Don’t Leave the Stage Without a Way to Stay in Touch

Ally says she kicks herself now for how many times she spoke, received great feedback and never saw those people again. Since realising the importance of building a list, she has put something in place to think about where she wants people to go and what she wants them to do after an event. That might be an opt-in, an SMS burst, or her daily dose of courage, which people love.

The aim is to connect with people in the audience so she can keep in touch through the weekly newsletter. Most people who enjoy a talk want to know more. They are curious, and their thinking has been elevated in some way, so the connection should continue.

I mentioned Keith Abraham’s idea that a speaking engagement is the start of a conversation. Speaking is not for everybody, but if you can work out your version of it, and your message works across multiple types of audiences, it makes sense to speak to plenty of people and build your list that way.

The Echo of Life: Put the Effort In Now

Ally often thinks about an Ed Mylett episode called The Echo of Life. As she describes it, the idea is that whatever effort you put in now, you will eventually see the benefits and reap the rewards. You just do not know when. It could be weeks, months or even years.

Running your own thought leadership practice has peaks and troughs, she says, and is a bit of a rollercoaster. What helps is “put your effort in now for your future results later”, even when you do not feel like it. In her own experience, the more she puts her foot down on the accelerator, the more the dial turns up three, six or 12 months later, and sometimes longer.

I added Keith Abraham’s line that activity solves inactivity. If nothing is happening, make something happen. Ally has done exactly that: she created events for her ideal clients, shared her IP, launched a podcast, wrote newsletters and is working on a book. She has also brought on support over the last 12 months, including virtual assistants, so that systems and follow-up are in place when she comes off stage and can focus on the creative work.

Advice for Consultants Who Are Just Starting Out

I asked Ally what she would tell someone who sees themselves in her story. She began with a caveat: she is not doing this all by herself.

Build a team around your gaps.

Ally is not interested in attention to detail, systemising, automation or data entry, which does not light her up. Others on her team love it. Find people who fill your gaps.

Be realistic about home support.

She has a husband who does a lot, and they are 50-50 in all things. She knows that is not the case for everyone, and she does not do all the things all the time.
Find a great coach.

Look for someone doing what you want to do at an exceptional level. Ally jumped in early on.
Build a community and an advisory panel.

Ally referred to Dunbar’s number, the proposal by anthropologist Robin Dunbar that people can maintain only a limited number of stable relationships. Her point was to choose carefully who sits on your panel of advisors and to get out of your own echo chamber. If people on your panel make you say “holy moly”, you have probably found the right people.

Keep a cadence.

Whether it is newsletters or publishing, stick to a rhythm and do the work.
Choose five things a day.

Women in particular, Ally says, tend to write “huge to-do lists that take longer to write than they do to execute”. Focus on what is important. Her hot tip: “email’s not one of them.” I agreed. The sooner you can outsource and delegate it, the better.

About Ally Nitschke

Ally Nitschke is a leadership communication expert based in Adelaide and the founder of Made for More. She works with leaders, teams and organisations on courageous leadership, courageous conversations and courageous teams. She hosts the Made for More podcast, and at the time of recording she was working on her book, Rise of the Courageous Leader. She is also a mother of four and a former professional ballet dancer.

Connect with Ally on LinkedIn | Made for More | Ally’s courageous conversations guide

Frequently Asked Questions

Can you build a consulting practice outside Sydney or Melbourne?

Yes. Ally Nitschke built hers from Adelaide. She initially wondered who would pay attention to her from there, but now says Adelaide is bigger than she assumed and that there is opportunity all over the place. Online delivery has also let her connect with people internationally.

How did Ally Nitschke get her first consulting clients?

Not by announcing her business and waiting. Her first 12 months produced little. Things changed after she met me at a Professional Speakers Australia event, started unpacking her ideas, and began publishing weekly LinkedIn newsletters and a podcast. People then contacted her after reading an article or hearing a podcast.

How often should consultants publish thought leadership content?

Ally did not name a universal frequency. She publishes a weekly newsletter on LinkedIn and plans her content and programs each month in her calendar, so there is a regular rhythm. Her point is that a steady cadence matters more than occasional bursts.

How do you know when to raise your consulting prices?

Ally let client feedback guide her. When a very experienced participant called her program the best leadership program she had ever done, Ally decided to take compliments at face value and charge a premium price for premium results. She raised prices in small steps and moved from single days to longer programs.

How does speaking help a consulting practice?

For Ally, speaking led to a flow-on effect after keynotes, with new introductions and conversations, and it helped her brand positioning. She adds that speakers should have a way to stay in touch, such as an opt-in, an SMS burst or a regular newsletter.

What advice does Ally give consultants who are just starting out?

Find a great coach, build a community and an advisory panel, keep a regular cadence, and build a team that covers the work you do not enjoy. She also recommends choosing five priorities a day rather than writing a huge to-do list.

Conclusion

Ally Nitschke’s story is not one of overnight success. Her practice grew in increments: a decision to start, a frustrating first year, a room full of speakers, a habit of unpacking and publishing her ideas, and a willingness to price her work in line with the results clients described.

For consultants who want to build a consulting practice, the pattern is worth borrowing. Get your ideas down and share them. Show up on a rhythm. Listen when clients tell you the value they received. Make sure every stage or published piece has a next step for the people who want more. And put the effort in now, knowing the echo may take some time to come back.

Work With Jane Anderson

If Ally’s story resonated with you, here are some ways to take the next step:

Women With Influence: Join a community of B2B women consultants and advisors building stronger expert practices.

1:1 Coaching with Grow With Influence: Work with me on your positioning, pricing and growth strategy.

The Influencer Indicator: Take a free scorecard to see where the gaps are in your thought leadership, marketing and business development.

 

Key Takeaways from Today’s Episode:

 

Full Show Transcript:

 


Most of the guests interviewed are current or alumni members of the Women With Influence community. Click here to find out more

Previous
Previous

Episode 63- Business Coach for Bookkeepers: How Sharon Francisco Built a Practice on Confidence

Next
Next

Episode 61 - How to Build a Signature Program and a Niche Practice: Lessons from CFO Mentor Alena Bennett