Episode 88 - Rita Cincotta on Deliberate Leadership and Building a Consulting Practice

Jane Anderson Leadership Development Coach, Rita Cincotta

Podcast is also available on the versions below:

Get Notified Of Future Episodes on Apple Podcasts | Spotify | Youtube


 
Jane Anderson's Show with Rita Cincotta

Rita Cincotta spent two decades in corporate HR before she made the leap into running her own consulting practice. Along the way, she led people teams across technology, healthcare, financial services, aged care, media, FMCG, and higher education, and now serves as a facilitator, speaker, coach, author, and non-executive director, including several board positions at Peninsula Health.

Her latest book, You Are How You Lead, centres on a concept she calls "deliberate leadership." In this conversation on The Jane Anderson Show, Rita unpacked what that phrase actually means, how she built self-trust while growing her own practice, and why so many leaders end up in roles they never consciously chose.

This article pulls out the practical lessons from that conversation for anyone leading a team, building a consulting business, or deciding whether leadership is even the right path for them.

Who Is Rita Cincotta?

Rita Cincotta built her career inside large organisations before starting her own practice roughly five and a half years ago. Her corporate HR roles spanned industries as varied as technology, healthcare, financial services, not-for-profit, aged care, advertising, media, FMCG, and higher education.

Today, she holds several non-executive positions at Peninsula Health, the major public health service for Frankston and the Mornington Peninsula, including chair of the People and Safety and Well-being Committee, and non-executive director roles on the Quality and Clinical Governance Committee and the Client Advisory Committee. She has spoken at national and international events on team performance, cultural transformation, change management, resilience, and workplace methodologies, and is the author of two books, most recently You Are How You Lead.

From HR Executive to Independent Consultant

Rita describes her entrepreneurial streak as something inherited from her father, a migrant from Italy who built a landscape gardening business from scratch while working other jobs to support the family. That same drive eventually pushed her to leave a demanding executive HR role, one she describes as working 60 to 70 hour weeks under constant visibility, to start her own practice when her youngest child was still a toddler.

"If I don't jump off now and do my own thing, I'm probably never going to do it," she recalled thinking at the time.

Running her own practice hasn't necessarily meant working fewer hours. But it has given her more control over when and how she works, along with a different kind of motivation behind the effort.

Non-Executive Roles at Peninsula Health

Alongside her consulting work, Rita holds three non-executive roles at Peninsula Health, spanning people and well-being, clinical governance, and client advisory functions. These board-level positions, combined with her consulting client base in higher education and healthcare, reflect where she says she spends the majority of her professional time: sectors she describes as complex, diverse, and personally meaningful to her.

What Is Deliberate Leadership?

Deliberate leadership is Rita's framework for how leaders should approach the role with intention, not by accident. The word "deliberate" became central to her practice after a period of what she calls "challenging soul searching" while trying to define her positioning as a coach.

Why Leaders Are Often "Seduced" Into the Role

One of Rita's core observations is that many leaders never actually choose to lead. Instead, they're recognised for being strong technical experts, and leadership is offered as a kind of reward, often with a salary bump or promotion attached.

The problem, she explains, is that very few people stop to ask whether they actually want to lead before accepting that offer. Leadership isn't simply a technical job with some management responsibilities layered on top; it comes with a different set of demands entirely.

Choosing to Lead vs. Being Promoted Into It

Rita works with leaders who are, in her words, miserable in the role, not because they're incapable, but because they never made a deliberate choice to be there. Her coaching often starts with helping someone either recommit consciously to leadership or recognise that the path isn't right for them after all.

This distinction matters because leaders who consciously choose the role tend to bring more resilience and clarity to it, rather than treating it as an obligation that came with a job title.

Building Self-Trust as a Consultant

Growing a consulting practice involves a lot of uncertainty: inconsistent income, unclear next steps, and decisions with no obvious right answer. Rita points to self-trust, or what she calls conviction, as the quality that lets her navigate that uncertainty without becoming paralysed by it.

The Role of Conviction in Uncertain Times

Rita traces her sense of conviction back to her upbringing, describing a deep, almost unconditional belief that things will work out, not because every plan succeeds as expected, but because she trusts she'll find another way to the outcome if the original plan falls through.

This isn't about assuming everything will go smoothly. It's a mindset that treats setbacks as redirections rather than failures, which she says makes her more adaptable in both her thinking and her approach to problems.

"Blind Optimism" and Staying Adaptable

Rita mentions taking the Harrison Assessments diagnostic tool at a client's request and coming out as what the tool categorises as a "blind optimist", someone who scores positively on optimism even when there are visible challenges or roadblocks ahead.

She reframes this trait as an asset rather than a blind spot. Her internal question is never "can I" or "should I": it's "how do I." That reframing shifts her energy towards solutions instead of getting stuck on whether something is possible in the first place.

She also credit Marcus Buckingham's strengths-based framework as a major influence, particularly the idea that leaning into your strengths strengthens you, while over-focusing on weaknesses can weaken you. Rather than trying to "fix" her own impatience, for example, Rita has built a team around her that compensates for it, reducing its impact without spending energy trying to eliminate a trait that's simply part of who she is.

Positioning and Niching Your Practice

When Rita first launched her practice, referrals came quickly: former colleagues who knew her from her corporate HR career reached out with work. But that initial wave didn't last.

Why Generalists Struggle to Get Repeat Clients

About six months in, the phone stopped ringing. Rita realised the issue: in a corporate role, being a generalist works because you're leading specialists underneath you. In an independent practice, that same generalist positioning confuses the market: people don't know exactly what to call you for.

She describes this as a positioning problem. Clients remember you for a specific identity you've created; without a deliberate, clear positioning, that identity gets muddled, and referrals dry up.

Leaning Into Higher Education and Healthcare

While Rita has worked across a broad mix of industries over the years, she has concentrated most of her time in higher education and healthcare. She's drawn to the complexity within these sectors, professional and administrative staff, clinical and non-clinical roles, academic and non-academic functions, along with their mix of public and private funding structures.

Rita is candid that niching down doesn't mean abandoning variety altogether. It means being intentional about where the bulk of your expertise and energy goes, so the market has a clear reason to call you.

Pricing With Confidence

Pricing consulting services is one of the more common struggles Rita sees, particularly among women building their own practices. Her advice centres on matching value to the market rather than simply lowering rates to win work.

Why New Clients Are the Time to Set Your Rate

Rita compares raising your rate with an existing client to trying to negotiate a raise in your current job. It's possible, but it's far easier to set a new benchmark with a new client than to renegotiate an existing relationship.

Her recommendation: if you want to charge more, start at that higher rate with new business relationships rather than trying to inch up existing ones over time.

Adding Value Instead of Discounting

Rather than lowering a quote when a client hesitates on price, Rita focuses on increasing the perceived and real value of the offer. That might mean adding an extra coaching session, a bonus master class, or additional resources that don't cost significant extra time but meaningfully increase what the client receives.

She also notes the difficulty of saying no to work, something she links partly to her upbringing, but argues that turning down work that doesn't fit your niche actually reinforces your expertise. Clients come to understand your pricing because they understand exactly what you specialise in.

Building a Support Team

Rita is clear that she doesn't run her practice alone. Her support structure includes a business manager, a couple of virtual assistants, a graphic designer, a bookkeeper, and an accountant, roughly five or six people in her core team.

Hiring a Business Manager to Manage You

When hiring her business manager, Rita specifically asked whether the person would be comfortable managing her, not just supporting her. She describes herself as someone who jumps between ideas, and says she needed someone with strong attention to detail to keep her grounded, since detail isn't her own strength.

Delegating Outside Your Strengths

Rita's approach to delegation is straightforward: bring in people who are strong where you're not. She points to design work as an example: rather than spending hours in Canva herself, she works with a graphic designer, freeing her time for the parts of the business only she can do.

Balancing a Consulting Practice and Family Life

Running a practice alongside a family isn't something Rita treats as a solved problem. She describes it as ongoing trial and error, built around a small set of non-negotiables.

Non-Negotiables: Exercise, Nutrition, Family Meals

Rita trains four mornings a week and includes a strength session with her teenage daughter once or twice a week. Family meals are treated as a fixed point in the day, even when travel or late client work makes it harder to maintain. She's also direct about the connection between her routines and how she shows up for clients: when exercise, food, or sleep slip, she says the rest of her performance suffers too.

Running the Household Like a Team

Rita and her husband, Darren, both run their own businesses and manage the household as a shared operation, including their children in age-appropriate responsibilities. They aim for a weekly planning conversation to coordinate school events and commitments, acknowledging they can't attend everything but try to divide responsibilities fairly between them.

What Rita Would Do Differently

Asked what she'd change if she were starting her practice over again, Rita didn't point to a single decision. She pointed to pace.

Slowing Down to Build Sustainable Systems

Rita says she would have intentionally slowed down in the early stages to build proper systems, rather than pushing through every task herself. She acknowledges this feels counterintuitive while you're trying to grow a business, but argues that skipping systems in favour of speed often costs more time later.

Managing Energy, Not Just Time

Rita distinguishes between time, which is finite, and energy, which she says can be deliberately managed. Pushing at maximum effort indefinitely, she warns, leads to burnout, and potentially resentment towards the very practice you built. Building systems might mean a goal takes an extra six or twelve months to reach, but it gets you there in a way that's sustainable rather than accidental.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is deliberate leadership?

Deliberate leadership, as defined by Rita Cincotta, is the practice of consciously choosing to lead rather than accepting leadership as an automatic reward for technical skill. It involves ongoing intentionality about how and why you lead.

How do you know if you actually want to be a leader?

Rita suggests leaders should regularly ask themselves whether they've genuinely chosen to lead, or whether they slipped into the role because it came with a promotion or salary increase. If the role feels like an obligation rather than a choice, it may be worth reassessing.

How can consultants price their services with confidence?

Rita recommends setting your intended rate with new clients rather than trying to raise prices with existing ones, and focusing on adding value (extra sessions, resources, or bonuses) instead of discounting when a client hesitates.

Why is niching important for a consulting practice?

Without a clear niche, potential clients don't know exactly what to call you for, which can cause referrals to dry up after an initial wave of goodwill-based work.

How does Rita Cincotta balance running a business and family life?

Rita protects a small set of non-negotiables (regular exercise, family meals, and shared household responsibilities with her husband) while acknowledging that balance is an ongoing, imperfect process rather than something fully solved.

What industries does Rita Cincotta specialise in?

While Rita has worked across many sectors, she spends most of her time in higher education and healthcare, drawn to the complexity and diversity within those industries.

Conclusion

Rita Cincotta's story isn't a straight line from corporate HR executive to confident consultant. It's a practice built through trial and error, around positioning, pricing, self-trust, and a deliberate approach to leadership that she continues to refine. For anyone leading a team or building their own consulting business, her experience offers a practical reminder: intention, not just effort, is what makes leadership and entrepreneurship sustainable.

To hear the full conversation, including more on Rita's career path and her book You Are How You Lead, listen to the complete episode above, or on Spotify or YouTube.

Work With Jane Anderson

Want more stories like this from women building world-class consulting practices? Explore how Jeanette Cremor built real project leadership impact, how Samantha Rush uses psychological safety to shape decision-making, or how Kylee Leota built her thought leadership practice.

Ready to position your own practice with the same clarity Rita describes? Explore Jane Anderson's 1:1 coaching for consultants and thought leaders, or find out more about Women with Influence.

 

Key Takeaways from Today’s Episode:

 

Full Show Transcript:

 


Most of the guests interviewed are current or alumni members of the Women With Influence community. Click here to find out more

Previous
Previous

Episode 89 - Alessandra Edwards: High-Performance & Well-Being Coach, Genetic Strategy Mentor & Author

Next
Next

Episode 87- Melanie Marshall on Building an Adaptive Culture Consulting Practice