Episode 40- Psychological Safety and Personal Branding: Dr Amy Silver on Building Trust by Being Yourself

Jane Anderson Interview with Interpersonal Safety Expert Dr. Amy Silver

Podcast is also available on the versions below:

Get Notified Of Future Episodes on Apple Podcasts | Spotify


 

People buy from people they know, like and trust. When I think about that last word, trust, I think of Dr Amy Silver.

In this episode of The Jane Anderson Show, I spoke with Amy, a psychologist, speaker, author and mentor who works on psychological safety: the conditions that let people be open, collaborate and perform. I mentored and coached Amy a couple of years before we recorded, so I was delighted to finally share her thinking with you.

We covered two things. First, how Amy's work on psychological safety plays out inside teams and organisations. Second, what it means for experts like you, who are building a personal brand under your own name and often working without a team around you. Amy was candid about her own journey, including the parts of her background she once kept hidden.

Why Trust Sits at the Centre of a Personal Brand

Before Amy joined me, I set the scene with a theme I return to often. As Tom Peters would say, a brand is a promise to the marketplace and to the world. When I work with people on their personal brand, the question underneath is whether they are a trusted brand. Does the promise you make match the behaviour of your teams, and the experience of a customer who comes to you?

That question runs through my book on trust, The Trust Edge: The Level Above Influence. It covers nine key skills for building trust in yourself as a leader and as a brand, including authenticity, empathy, credibility, your identity as a leader and vulnerability. Trust is no longer about command and control. It is about connection, compassion, insight and understanding. Many people assume personal branding is mostly about how you dress and present yourself. That is not a bad place to start, but there is more to it. You can find the book, with a complimentary download, on my Books page.

Meet Dr Amy Silver

Amy is a psychologist, speaker, author and mentor focused on building cultures of courageous collaboration. Her background includes a doctorate in clinical psychology, work as a practising clinical psychologist, and a role as an academic tutor and researcher at Oxford University in the UK. She has also spent 15 years in corporate settings applying psychological knowledge, trust and collaboration to improve growth, and had a short stint as a professional actress.

Amy is based in Melbourne, works across a broad range of industries, and is the founder of the Safe Space Program, which helps leaders build trust and connection in their teams. Her book, Conversations Create Growth, shows managers how to lead performance conversations that drive engagement and achievement. When we recorded, she was working on a new book, The Safe Space.

Amy described her work simply: she helps people have stronger relationships. Through those relationships, she said, people get more done and feel good while they are doing it. Many of her clients are government agencies and professional services firms. In her view, that world has focused on building trust with clients, and people are now realising how much trust inside the organisation affects their efficiency. To create a high performance team, she said, they need trust and safety.

Psychological Safety vs Trust: What's the Difference?

I met Amy at Thought Leaders Business School. When I first heard her explain psychological safety, my reaction was, “Oh, that's what it is.” I had always thought of it as trust and rapport. So I asked her directly whether trust and psychological safety are the same thing.

Amy said they probably share a root, which is the emotion of fear, and that safety is almost its opposite. For her, psychological safety is about being okay with what you think and who you are, and bringing that to the table. In any group, she explained, we carry expectations of how we should be. When we feel safe, we can draw on all the different parts of ourselves. We do not put up a maze of yeses and nos to work out what will be accepted. Am I being funny enough, open enough, vulnerable enough, strong enough, clear enough, cool enough? That mental fog, she said, gets in the way of accessing what our clever brains can do.

She breaks the work into three questions:

  • How do I bring the best version of myself? That is something each of us is in charge of.

  • How do I get the best out of the people around me? Am I taking responsibility for what others can access, or am I inhibiting what they bring?

  • Do we understand what we can do together? If we truly nailed our shared purpose, could we do more?

Team trust has a long history in the business literature. I mentioned Patrick Lencioni's The Five Dysfunctions of a Team, which talks a lot about trust and about connection within teams as a route to high performance. For wider context beyond our conversation, a Harvard Business Review explainer drawing on Harvard Business School professor Amy Edmondson describes team psychological safety as a shared belief that it is okay to take risks, speak up and admit mistakes without fear of negative consequences.

Why Self-Leadership Comes First

Amy's programs always start with the individual. Collaboration, she said, starts with the individual: you have to understand yourself to be a good collaborator. Do you know what triggers your thinking and behaviour when you are in a group? Do you know what intimidates you, frustrates you, makes you complacent or makes you go silent? If you cannot be conscious of those things, she said, you are not taking charge of who you are and what you have to offer.

I put it to her that organisations are being asked to do more with less and to cope with constant change. If I can be myself in my team, I can probably cope with that disruption, think creatively and risk failing. The question underneath is whether I will still be accepted in my tribe if I have a go.

Amy agreed, and described how workplaces have changed. Egos used to prevail and people followed the leader. Now things move too fast and there is too much chaos. We do not have time to build relationships, so we cannot rely on time as the main feeder for trust. With the threat of jobs being taken by robots, she said, we need to polish our human skills. Our superpower is our ability to flex who we are, but for some reason we tune out of that when we are younger and decide we are set. To make better connections with more people, faster, we need to flex around our own styles and behaviours.

How Amy Builds Safety Inside Organisations

In her client work, Amy generally starts at the leadership level and filters down, because leaders set the tone. Sometimes leadership teams are not as brave as they need to be for a program like this, so she starts in the middle and works up. Her focus is on small groups rather than big ones. She described sending a “positive virus” through an organisation by creating little hubs of safety in teams, which can then collaborate across the organisation and shift the cultural tone.

Each person first goes through self-leadership, understanding how they perform and react around other people. Then the team works on trust building. She was clear that this is not walking across hot coals. It is about driving connection so people can have honest, authentic relationships based on who they really are.

The aim is courageous conversations rather than polite ones, where people only say what they mean once they have left the room. Polite conversations, Amy said, lead to inefficiencies. If workplace culture is your area, you may also enjoy my conversation with Melanie Marshall in Episode 87, on building an adaptive culture consulting practice.

When Fear Gets in the Way of Trust

Amy sees many behaviours in meetings and organisations that come from fear, and that fear tends to go one of two ways. Some people become defensive and hide who they are, batting things away when someone gets close. She knows she has to move around their maze to get inside. Others are fearful and pull back, and it is hard to trust them because you do not know what they are thinking.

Either way, she said, fear pushes people away. If someone senses you are fearful, it is hard to trust you because they do not know where you will go next: into defence or into anxiety. She sees the same thing in selling. A fearful, desperate look, the “I'll do anything that you want me to do” energy, makes trust difficult.

Compare that with someone who says, “That's really lovely to be asked to do that, but I don't do that. That's not my thing.” Amy finds that easy to trust. She can see the boundaries and the clarity about who that person is and what they do.

Amy's Own Story: From Saying Yes to Everything to Standing in Her Uniqueness

Amy was open about what has not gone well for her. Before she built her brand, she had a strong understanding of how people change and why they think and behave as they do, drawn from psychology and from acting. She could train people to present better or to change in whatever direction they wanted. So she created a company offering lots of different things to lots of different people. She was marketing herself as a trainer or facilitator, and if you asked her to do anything, she said yes.

She tried to be what she thought a good trainer would be, and she felt fraudulent. Trying to be the expert in everything and anything felt a bit weird. Over the last few years, with my mentoring as one of the influences, she has stood tall in what she uniquely brings. That, she said, has made it easier to be authentic and not apologetic. She can be quite real. If she makes a cheeky joke, she does not have to agonise over it afterwards.

In her words, she can just be herself, and “if they like it, then they buy it. And if they don't, then they won't.” People trust her quickly because they quickly see who she is.

I pointed out that Amy is almost her own case study. She has had to create safety for herself, with the self-talk of “Even if you fail today or if you don't get that sale today, I'm still going to love you.” You have to be your own best friend in this game. Amy called that a really good summary.

Trust Starts With You, Not With the Other Person

When we try to build trust, Amy said, we tend to look to the other person to create it for us: can I trust this person? But “it's my responsibility to create that trust.” If she gets knocked back, it is her decision whether to go again. She cannot passively wait for someone else to trust her. She has to go and get it, and work hard to create it. She also has to work out whether she wants to work with that person. If she does not think she can make them feel safe enough to be themselves, she does not necessarily want to work with them.

I think that is valuable for female personal brands in particular. We are selling ourselves and the work we know how to do, and in the early days it is tempting to sit back and wonder, “Am I good enough?” The fear underneath can be fear of rejection, fear of not making enough money, fear of not being able to pay the bills. Amy added the fear of saying the wrong thing, and the overthinking that follows. Her answer is to stand in who you are and be clear on your style and personality. Then you cannot trip up, because they either want it or they don't, and at least you are clear about what you are saying and doing.

This reminded me of something I heard recently from either Matt Church or Peter Cook: intention over perfection. If you come with a high level of positive intent, even a fumbled word still creates connection. It also connects with Michael Port's red velvet rope policy in Book Yourself Solid, which says who is let in and who is not. I think a boundary like that around your work contributes to psychological safety, and Amy agreed.

Walking Into the Boardroom as Yourself

Amy gave a vivid example. She walked into boardrooms full of dark mahogany, shiny glass and men in suits who seemed very impressive, and felt her psychological safety drop. She was clear that the room was not doing it to her. It was something she was doing, a spike in her expectations of what they needed to see before they would connect with her.

In the past, she would have tried to fit in. She would have put on heels and lipstick, tied her hair back, and done her best to look as if she should be there, even though that probably was not what they wanted to see. Now she just shows up as herself. If they do not like it, she does not want to be in that room either. “I can't pretend anymore,” she said. Her position is simple: this is what I know, this is what I can do, and if you want it, let's do it.

The Part of Her Brand Amy Once Kept Secret

I asked Amy about her acting background, because it is such an interesting part of her brand. She said it connects to the same conversation. Only over the last year had it emerged for her, because she had been keeping it secret. How could a serious corporate person have had a couple of years of professional acting, not particularly successful by her own account, and then sell big programs to important people? Now her answer is, of course, it is me.

Acting is where she learned some of her trade. Beyond the words on a script, she said, there is something ethereal that happens in a high performing team: good communication, good eye contact, play, clear boundaries, positive regard and a hope that you are creating something together. These are fundamental to teamwork, and the more fear there is among the players, the worse the performance gets. She also described how good actors and a good director spend time building individual relationships outside the written text. You might spend a day together in character with no script, so that the audience can feel the connection between two people without seeing the background work.

Amy mentioned Simon Dowling, an improviser and actor we both know, who also works on trust, connection and psychological safety. She believes there is something fundamental about being light and playful in relationships. We layer on roles and expectations, but in acting there is no time for that. You play, and it is light and fun. For a while she felt ashamed of her acting past, “which is crazy, isn't it?”, because it meant hiding big sections of her life.

This is why I encourage my clients to look at the metaphors in their own lives. Clients often say, “Really? That's relevant?” Once they unpack it, they find a parallel that helps people learn faster. It also makes you unique. Anyone could be invited to talk about trust and psychological safety, but people want the Dr Amy Silver version, with the acting techniques she brings. That is how you move from commoditisation to a high value personal brand, and there is only one of you. If you are weighing up whether to lead with your own name, you may also like my conversation with Gillian Smith in Episode 99 on personal brand versus business brand.

Odd Socks, Cognitive Diversity and Standing Further Into Who You Are

Amy shared that her plan for the year was to be much more strategic with her social media. One theme she is passionate and vocal about is diversity. One of the benefits of psychological safety, she said, is more cognitive diversity. If there is a very dominant voice in the room, or people are not connected, you lose the diversity of thinking you could have. She sees that as one of the key benefits of working with her, and she is passionate about all kinds of diversity, including gender.

While discussing this with her social media planner, she said she even likes diversity in socks. She always wears odd socks, because she does not like pairs. Her planner said that would be a perfect thing to use on social media. Amy admitted she had always hidden it, and before an important meeting she would put on matching socks because it felt like the right thing to do.

Even small things like that, she said, show her she can keep standing further into who she is. The more she thinks about it, and the more she surrounds herself with people who are strong in their conviction of who they are and what their brand is, the more confident she feels standing in who she is and not trying to be them.

Why Experts Need a Tribe

I added that even if you are out on your own as a personal brand, you need to surround yourself with a tribe. This is lonely work. To hack your own psychological safety while you are selling yourself, you need a sense of connection with people who will still be there if you do something wrong or fail along the way. That gives you the opportunity to try things, or to see others do something and think, “Maybe I could do that.”

Amy saw this in herself. At the beginning of building Dr Amy Silver, she often looked at other people with a critical eye: how are they putting themselves front and centre, and who gives them the right? She said that thinking holds you back, because you then assume other people are thinking the same about you. Her advice is to get over it, because people think what they need to think. You have to go cold turkey and get it done. It is a bit squeamish at the beginning, but the more you do, the more you realise it is a game and you are just trying things out.

When she sees others trying a different angle, such as videos or campaigns, she asks what would make sense for her. It is much nicer, she said, to watch and observe other people playing the game too. It is fun.

Conclusion

Amy's message to me was that trust and safety start with the individual. Fear pushes people away, whether it shows up as defensiveness or as holding back. Clarity about who you are and what you do makes you easy to trust, and it is your responsibility to create that trust rather than wait for it. Her journey from saying yes to everything, to standing in her own style and even her odd socks, shows what that looks like in practice.

For experts building a personal brand, the practical question is where you are still trying to be what you think someone else wants to see. Start there. Be clear, set your boundaries, and find people who help you bring out the parts of you that you might never consider showing alone.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is psychological safety?

For Dr Amy Silver, it is being okay with what you think and who you are, and bringing that to the table. When people feel safe, they can draw on all the different parts of themselves instead of putting up barriers or trying to present who they think will be accepted.

Is psychological safety the same as trust?

Amy said the two probably share a root in the emotion of fear, with safety almost the opposite of it. She described safety as being okay with what you think and who you are, and bringing that to the table.

How does fear affect trust in a personal brand?

Amy sees fear showing up as defensiveness and hiding, or as holding back. Both make it hard for people to know what you are thinking and where you will go next. In selling, a desperate willingness to do anything makes trust harder, while clear boundaries make it easier.

Why does self-leadership come first?

Amy said collaboration starts with you. To be a good collaborator, you need to understand what triggers your thinking and behaviour in groups, including what intimidates you, frustrates you, makes you complacent or makes you silent.

How can an expert build trust without a team?

Amy's approach is to take responsibility for creating trust, to be clear about what you do and do not do, and to be yourself. I would add that a tribe of people who support you through failures makes it easier to try new things.

Why share unexpected parts of your background, like acting?

Amy kept her acting history secret for a while and felt ashamed of it. Now she sees that it is where she learned important lessons about teamwork, and I think it makes her brand unique. People want the version of an expert that only that person can offer.

Connect with Dr Amy Silver

Visit dramysilver.com to find Amy's work, speaking, programs and her book. When we recorded, she said her social handles are also under the name Dr Amy Silver.

Work With Jane Anderson

If Amy's story resonated with you, here are some ways to take the next step:

✨ Tune in to hear Dr Amy Silver on psychological safety, the fear that undermines trust, and why being clear and real is the foundation of a trusted personal brand.


Key Takeaways from Today’s Episode:

 

Full Show Transcript:

 


Most of the guests interviewed are current or alumni members of the Women With Influence community. Click here to find out more

Previous
Previous

Episode 41 - Small Business Failure Rate in Australia: What Nick Barnsdall's Research Says About Surviving and Scaling

Next
Next

Episode 34- Interview with Productivity Expert Donna McGeorge