Episode 91- What Is Attuned Leadership? Dr Michelle Pizer's Framework for Better Leaders

Jane Anderson Leadership Expert, Executive Coach, and Organisational Psychologist, Dr Michelle Pizer

Podcast is also available on the versions below:

Get Notified Of Future Episodes on Apple Podcasts | Spotify | Youtube


 
Jane Anderson's Show with Michelle Pizer

Some leaders seem to know exactly what their people need before they ask for it. They notice when someone is struggling, they open doors at the right moment, and they somehow bring out the best in everyone around them, all while still hitting the organisation's targets.

Dr Michelle Pizer has a name for this: attuned leadership.

Pizer is an organisational psychologist and executive coach who has spent her career studying and teaching this approach. She holds a PhD built on the topic, has coached leaders inside Google, KPMG, BHP, and Goldman Sachs, and has been featured in Business Insider, Channel 9, Radio National, The Age, and news.com.au.

In a conversation on the Jane Anderson Show episode with Dr Michelle Pizer, Pizer explained where attuned leadership comes from, how it works in practice, and why more senior leaders are turning to it, particularly in the aftermath of restructures. This article breaks down her framework and what it means for anyone trying to lead people well.

Dr Michelle Pizer's Path to Attuned Leadership

Pizer's route into organisational psychology wasn't planned. She first encountered psychology almost by accident, choosing it as an elective subject in her first year of university without knowing what the word meant. She did well enough to be singled out by her dean, a moment she has described as pivotal, given she grew up alongside three siblings she considers gifted.

From there, her career took several turns before settling. She worked in marketing, then HR, then spent time in management consulting at what was then Ernst & Young, before moving into market research, where her analytical strengths in statistics and research design stood out.

A turning point came after her father passed away. Facing that kind of loss led her to question the direction of her career, and she left her job without another one lined up. She began working with adults with mild intellectual disabilities, started (and later converted) a master's degree, and spent four years volunteering as a counsellor in a community agency, all before starting the PhD that would eventually shape her professional identity.

It was during her PhD research into emotions and relationships in the workplace, combined with weekly supervision from a psychoanalyst she calls "the great one," that the ideas behind attuned leadership took shape. She was simultaneously building her private practice, cold-emailing doctors from a printed directory to generate her first referrals, a process that took three months to produce a single client.

That practice grew into the coaching and consulting work she does today, working primarily one-on-one with senior leaders, alongside some organisational consulting, speaking, and training. This grounding, built from years of clinical listening combined with formal research into workplace psychology, is part of what distinguishes attuned leadership from leadership advice based on personal opinion or anecdote alone.

What Is Attuned Leadership?

Attuned leadership is a style of leading that centres on being genuinely connected to, and in touch with, the people you lead, rather than managing purely through authority, process, or output.

The idea grew out of Pizer's academic background in the psychodynamics of organisations, an area she studied at both master's and PhD level. It draws directly on the work of psychoanalyst Donald Winnicott, particularly his concept of a "holding environment": the setting a parent creates to help a child feel safe and secure enough to develop.

Pizer first began applying this thinking not in a classroom, but on the job. Early in her career, she was put in charge of a research team for the first time and had no established playbook for how to lead it. She found herself drawing on the idea of a "good enough" parent: someone responsive to what a person actually needs, not just what's expected of them.

That responsiveness is the core of attuned leadership. As Pizer put it, it's about listening not just to the words someone says, but to what's underneath them, the same way a parent learns to read an infant who has no words at all.

Why Attunement Matters More Than Authority

Traditional leadership models often emphasise direction-setting and accountability. Attuned leadership doesn't discard those things, but it starts from a different place: understanding what an individual actually wants for their own career, then working out how to meet the organisation's needs and the person's needs at the same time.

Pizer has been explicit that this isn't about forcing people into a predetermined mould. Each person she's led has needed something slightly different, much like, she notes, no two children have identical needs. An attuned leader's job is to notice that difference and respond to it.

How Attuned Leaders Operate Day to Day

Attuned leadership isn't an abstract philosophy, it shows up in specific, repeatable behaviours. Based on Pizer's own account of leading teams and coaching executives, three stand out.

Listening Beyond the Words

The starting point is always listening, properly, not performatively. Pizer describes this as picking up on what's going on for someone beneath the surface, especially when they're overwhelmed or have just received feedback they didn't want to hear.

In her coaching work, she's found that people often can't think clearly or problem-solve effectively until they feel heard and validated first. Skipping that step and jumping straight to solutions tends to backfire.

Tailoring Development to the Individual

Once a leader understands what someone needs, the next step is closing the gap between where that person is and where they want to go, through mentoring, training, or hands-on support, depending on what actually fits.

Pizer has described this phase as intensive at first, particularly because people don't always know what they need themselves. Part of an attuned leader's role is helping someone figure that out before any development plan can work.

Knowing When to Step Back

The final piece, and often overlooked, is letting go. Once someone has built the skills and confidence they need, an attuned leader steps back rather than continuing to manage closely.

Pizer has called this the most rewarding part of the process, describing the growth she's seen in people she's led this way as dramatic once they're given room to run, a shift some describe as "exponential," or a hockey-stick curve of sudden capability.

It's worth being honest about the trade-off here: attuned leadership takes more effort upfront than simply issuing instructions. Pizer has acknowledged that working out what someone genuinely needs (particularly when they don't know themselves) can be intensive in the early stages. The pay-off comes later, once that person can operate independently and a leader can genuinely let go, rather than continuing to check in out of habit or anxiety.

This is also where attuned leadership differs most clearly from micromanagement dressed up as support. The goal isn't ongoing closeness for its own sake, it's building someone's capability to the point where close supervision is no longer necessary.

Why Senior Leaders Are Turning to Attuned Leadership Now

Pizer's client base has shifted over the years, but a consistent pattern has emerged among the senior leaders she works with today. It also reflects a broader shift in Australian workplaces: psychosocial hazards, including poor support and low psychological safety, are now formally recognised under Australian work health and safety law, giving leaders a regulatory reason, not just a cultural one, to take this seriously.

Leading Teams Through Restructures

At the time of her conversation with Jane Anderson, Pizer noted that restructuring (and specifically the unintended consequences of restructuring) had come up with three separate clients in a single month. She's typically brought in to work with the people left managing the fallout: senior, but no longer as senior as they were, and dealing with teams that are unsettled as a result.

Attuned leadership becomes especially relevant here, because it gives leaders a way to rebuild trust and re-engage people who feel like they've lost ground, without simply issuing new directives from the top. Safe Work Australia's Model Code of Practice on managing psychosocial hazards specifically flags poorly managed organisational change as a workplace risk, reinforcing why this kind of leadership matters most during and after restructures.

Retaining and Developing Ambitious Talent

Pizer draws a distinction between two groups of leaders she coaches. More senior leaders, including CEOs, tend to focus on how to get more out of their people and become a better boss. Leaders in or aspiring to the C-suite tend to be more focused on their own career progression, driven by ambition that Pizer says she genuinely enjoys working with.

In both cases, she's found that leaders often underestimate the impact they have on the people around them. Becoming more attuned, both to themselves and to their teams, tends to help leaders get where they want to go, simply because people work better, and stay longer, under leaders who make them feel safe and understood.

How to Start Practising Attuned Leadership

Attuned leadership isn't a certification or a fixed program, it's a practice that develops over time. Based on Pizer's own approach, a few starting points stand out for any leader who wants to build it:

  • Listen before you respond. Resist the urge to solve a problem before someone feels heard.

  • Ask what the person wants, not just what the role requires of them.

  • Expect to invest time upfront. Tailoring support to an individual takes more effort early on, but pays off once they're operating independently.

  • Deliberately stepping back once someone has the skills to succeed, continuing to manage closely after that point can undermine the growth you've helped create.

  • Notice your own impact. Even experienced, senior leaders can underestimate how their behaviour affects the people around them.

Leaders who want to go deeper into this way of working may benefit from executive coaching built around your team.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is attuned leadership?

Attuned leadership is a leadership approach focused on being genuinely connected to and responsive to the people you lead. It involves listening closely, understanding what someone needs to grow, and adjusting your support to the individual rather than applying a one-size-fits-all approach.

Where does the concept of attuned leadership come from?

The framework draws on the work of psychoanalyst Donald Winnicott, particularly his concept of a "holding environment": the safe, responsive setting a parent creates for a child. Dr Michelle Pizer developed attuned leadership by applying this thinking to organisational and workplace psychology through her academic research and coaching practice.

How is attuned leadership different from other leadership styles?

Unlike leadership models built primarily around authority, process, or output, attuned leadership starts with genuinely understanding what an individual needs, both from the organisation and for their own career, before deciding how to lead them. It also emphasises stepping back once someone has developed the skills to work independently, rather than continuing to manage closely.

Can attuned leadership help after a company restructure?

Yes. Dr Michelle Pizer has worked with several clients navigating the unintended consequences of restructures, where teams often feel unsettled or have lost seniority. Attuned leadership offers a way to rebuild trust and re-engage people during that kind of transition.

Who is Dr Michelle Pizer?

Dr Michelle Pizer is an organisational psychologist and executive coach who developed the attuned leadership framework. She holds a PhD in the area of emotions and relationships in the workplace, has coached leaders at organisations including Google, KPMG, BHP, and Goldman Sachs, and has been featured in outlets including Business Insider, Channel 9, Radio National, The Age, and news.com.au.

Conclusion

Attuned leadership offers a research-backed alternative to command-and-control management, one built on genuinely understanding the people you lead, not just directing them. For senior leaders navigating restructures, disengagement, or simply trying to get more out of their teams, Dr Michelle Pizer's framework provides a practical starting point grounded in real psychological theory and years of coaching experience.

For a deeper look at how this plays out with real clients, listen to the full conversation between Dr Michelle Pizer and Jane Anderson.

Work With Jane Anderson

If Dr Michelle Pizer’s story resonated with you, here are some ways to take the next step:

  • Women With Influence:Join a community of B2B women consultants, coaches, and advisors building world-class practices

  • 1:1 Coaching:Work directly with Jane on your personal brand and business growth strategy

  • Influence Lab:Create a year’s worth of thought leadership content and turn your expertise into strategic assets for your consulting practice. 

 

Key Takeaways from Today’s Episode:

 

Full Show Transcript:

 


Most of the guests interviewed are current or alumni members of the Women With Influence community. Click here to find out more

Previous
Previous

Episode 92 - Real Project Leadership: The Recipe for Project Teams to Have Real Impact

Next
Next

Episode 90- How Psychological Safety Shapes Team Decision-Making: Samantha Rush